Writing 201 is an introductory course in the basic conventions and expectations of college essay writing. Students write essays in response to assigned readings from a range of college-level texts. The course covers how to state and support a thesis, develop unified and coherent supporting paragraphs, organize the various parts of an essay, and write clear and effective sentences. The course also introduces students to critical reading, reasoning, and writing.

This blog is a resource for instructors of Writing 201 at Irvine Valley College.

To participate in the blog, leave your comments below.

You can also contact the blog's editor, Professor Lisa Alvarez, at lalvarez@ivc.edu

Sunday, August 12, 2012

Typical First Assignment: Analysis

Here is Carrie Goulding's first assignment which is, like others, relatively brief (three pages).  She has her students focus immediately on analysis, using a series of directed exercises (also included here) which help build the essay.

FORMAL WRITING ASSIGNMENT # 1

Due dates: 

First Draft:  Friday, September 18

Final Draft:  Friday, September 25


Page requirement:  3 pages, 1 inch margins, double spaced, 12 point font


Format:  In top left corner of the first page please type the following information (single spaced):

                        Name:

                        Section #:

                        Date:

                        Essay Title:

 Assignment:   

In “Learning How to Read and Write” Douglass expresses his belief that education will set him free.  Would Malcolm X agree with this statement? 

Write a 4-5 paragraph essay responding to the above question.  Support your answer by citing to specific examples from both texts.

Prewriting Assignments:

1:  Due September 9 (work on in class)

Assignment:   Both Douglass and Malcolm X have a new perspective on life after learning how to read and write.  This perspective is both positive and negative.

Write one paragraph that explains in specific detail Frederick Douglass’s new perspective after learning how to read and write.  Describe what Douglass did to arrive at this new perspective. 

Write a second paragraph that explains in specific detail Malcolm X’s new perspective after learning how to read and write.  Describe what Malcolm X did to arrive at this new perspective.

Write a third paragraph comparing Malcolm X’s perspective on his life after learning

how to read with Frederick Douglass’s perspective on life after learning how to read.  Discuss how each perspective was similar and how it was different.


2:  Due September 14 (complete before you come to class)

             Assignment: 

Write a thesis statement that answers the following question:  Would Malcolm X agree with Frederick Douglass that education set him free?  Include a “because” in your sentence that explains your conclusion and a roadmap of the two or three main supporting points for your thesis.

Essay Template

Follow this outline as you write your first draft.

Paragraph 1—Introduction:

·         Two to three sentences that introduce the subject of your essay, including complete and correct names for the authors and works you are writing about. 

·         A thesis statement that includes a “because” and a roadmap of two or three supporting ideas. 

o   Example: 

§  Malcolm X would not agree with Frederick Douglass that education set him free because _(supporting point #1), (supporting point #2), and (supporting point #3).

 Paragraph 2—Supporting Point 1:

 ·         Begin with a topic sentence that restates supporting point #1 and also provides a “because” for supporting point #1. 

o   Example from text that supports point #1

o   Explain how this example supports point #1

o   Another example from text that supports point #1

o   Explain how this example supports point #1

·         Concluding sentence that summarizes point #1 and provides a bridge to the next paragraph.


Paragraph 3—Supporting Point 2:


·         Begin with a topic sentence that restates supporting point #2 and also provides a “because” for supporting point #2.

o   Example from text that supports point #2

o   Explain how this example supports point #2

o   Another example from text that supports point #2

o   Explain how this example supports point #2

·         Concluding sentence that summarizes point #2 and provides a bridge to the next paragraph.


Paragraph 4—Supporting Point 3:


·         Begin with a topic sentence that restates supporting point #3 and also provides a “because” for supporting point #3.

o   Example from text that supports point #3

o   Explain how this example supports point #3

o   Another example from text that supports point #3

o   Explain how this example supports point #3

·         Concluding sentence that summarizes point #3 and provides a bridge to the next paragraph.

Paragraph 5—Conclusion:

·         3 sentences (at least) that restate your thesis and provide a recommendation.


The Writing Conference


Concurrent enrollment in WR 280 is required for students in WR 201.  The instruction writing students receive in Writing center through WR 280 helps guide them to greater success in WR 201. Instructors in the writing center do not "edit" student work but take the time to review the assignment, discuss a particular issue (or two), review the draft  and direct the student.

In order to facilitate participation in WR 280 and to document student conferences, classroom instructors often develop forms like those below to assist their students - and the writing conference instructors.

Here are two sample forms for you to review and use as you wish.  One is general while the other is more  assignment specific. One is a single sheet while the other is two-sided.  Finally, notice that one instructor requires TWO conferences for the first assignment  and the other instructor requires an evaluation of the conference.

Instructors often post these conference sheets in Blackboard for the students to download as necessary.


Writing 280, Writing Conference
Learning to Read and Write Writing Assignment

This sheet must be completed and submitted with your final essay.

You must confer with an English instructor in the Writing Conference at least twice during the composition of this essay.  When you go to the Humanities Center for your conference, take with you your assignment sheet, all other pertinent handouts, and your writing in progress.  Make absolutely sure that the conference instructor understands your assignment, listen carefully to the instructor’s feedback and advice, ask questions, and remember to thank the instructor.

Each missed signature will subtract 10% from your final grade on this assignment.

First Draft Conference (must be completed no later than Friday, September 18)

                                                                                                                                   
Instructor’s Name                                             Instructor’s Signature & Date

What did you discuss with the instructor?


What do you need to focus on to turn your first draft into a polished final draft?




Final Draft Conference (must be completed no later than Friday, September 25)

                                                                                                                                   
Instructor’s Name                                             Instructor’s Signature & Date

What did you discuss with the instructor?




What changes can be made to improve your final draft?








Writing Center Conference Form                   Writing Conference Instructor: ________________
Writing 201/WR 280                                       Writing Conference Instructor’s Initials _________
Fall 2012                                                         Date and time of your visit: ___________________
Remember…
  • The Writing Center Conference Form MUST be complete in order for you to receive credit for your visit.  If you do not meet with a writing instructor and complete this sheet, your final essay will be returned to you, ungraded.
  • The Writing Center Sheet must be completed before the class session in which the essay is due.  The conference must be held so that you have enough time to incorporate the suggestions and guidance given.  If the conference time is judged to be insufficient, the final essay will be returned, ungraded.

Please complete this side BEFORE visiting the Writing Center
1.  At which stage of your writing process are you currently working (prewriting, rough draft, etc)?


2.  What (specifically) is working well for you at this stage of your writing? 



3.  What (specifically) are you having trouble with?  



4.  What would you like to discuss in your writing conference?  



5.  Create one specific, open-ended question for your writing conference instructor.  




Please complete this side AFTER your Writing Center Conference
1.  Write a short summary of your visit with the writing instructor.  How did the instructor help you?  What specific techniques or tips did he or she offer in response to your questions? 




2.  Evaluate the overall effectiveness of your conference.





 3. Will you schedule another conference for the essay is due?  Why or why not?


*

Here is Michelle Gray Mattoon's writing conference sheet:

Writing 280 Conference: Formal Essay # _____

Your Name _________________

Date of your conference: ______ WR 280 Instructor’s Name____________________________

WR 280 Instructor’s signature: _____________________________

For each question, write thorough responses and explanations.
Before you talk with a WR 280 instructor:

1.    Briefly summarize the Writing Prompt for the Formal Essay:









2.    If you already have one, state your thesis:









3.    Prepare three questions to ask so that the WR 180 instructor can help you as you complete your formal essay.


Question 1:

Question 2:


Question 3:




After the conference:

4.    Explain in detail how you plan to incorporate those suggestions and comments as you revise your essay.


Answer to Question 1:



Answer to Question 2:



Answer to Question 3:

Saturday, August 11, 2012

Grading Rubrics

Some instructors develop and use a grading rubric not only to guide their own evaluation of student work and to maintain standards, but to share with the students.  Some of these rubrics are adapted to specific assignments while others are more general and resemble the one used for the departmental diagnostic.

My experience is that students are receptive to these rubrics and fine them more valuable perhaps than the lengthy end notes I once wrote.  I still write in the margins on a final draft and often include a short narrative note - but I use a rubric now on which which I highlight the student's achievement.

Here is Sarah Bereiter's grading rubric for her first assignment. 


  Irvine Valley College, WR 201
Evaluation of Writing – Grading Rubric for Essay 1

Author: _________________________ Assignment: ____  Date: _____

Writing Outcomes
Scale
Focus
1.     Effectively, creatively, and successfully addresses the prompt.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
2.     Maintains a strong focus on the thesis throughout the essay.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
Development, Support, and Organization
3.     Reveals evidence of critical and creative thinking.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
4.     Supports the main idea through effective use of details, explanation of assertions, and description.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
5.     Presents ideas in a clear and logical order. 
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
6.     Uses transitions effectively to connect sentences and paragraphs.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
Readability, Style, and Format
7.     Contains few spelling, syntax, word-usage or punctuation errors.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
8.     Uses a tone that is appropriate to the audience and to the writing task, and strives to have an original voice.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
9.     Demonstrates strong command of language, and vocabulary is appropriate for college-level writing.
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor
Overall Evaluation
Excellent
Very Good
Adequate
Fair
Poor








Here is another approach to a grading rubric used by Carrie Goulding:

 MALCOLM X ASSIGNMENT:  GRADE EVALUATION

NAME:

GRADE:

Does the paper have a thesis that states the subject of the essay, a clear perspective on that subject, and provides a roadmap for the rest of the essay? (20 points)



Does the thesis (and the rest of the essay) respond directly to the assignment, which asks “Does Malcolm X in ‘Learning How to Read’ agree with Frederick Douglass that education will set him free”?  (20 points)



Do the supporting paragraphs begin with a signpost and include specific, well chosen examples that support the thesis well? (30 points)



Does the writer explain why each example supports the thesis?  (20 points)




Does the writer use a front door opener?
(10 points)



Has the writer completed all the prewriting and workshop activities?  (-10 points if not completed)


Does the writer have both signatures from the writing center?  (-10% for each missing signature)


Grade breakdown:  95-100 points=A, 90-94=A-, 86-89=B+, 83-85=B, 80-82=B-, 76-79=C+, 73-75=C, 70-72=C-, 66-69=D+, 63-65=D, 60-62=D-, 59 and below=F. 

If you decide to revise this essay, your revision is due a week after you receive your graded essay, at the beginning of class.  I will average this grade with your revised grade.  I would highly recommend taking this sheet with your essay to the writing center for review before you begin working on your revision.


Friday, August 10, 2012

WR 201 Curriculum

How is Writing 201 different from other writing courses at IVC?

How is it different from other courses taught at other colleges?

The answers begin in the curriculum.

As you design, revise and write your syllabus and assignments you should be directed by the curriculum which outlines topics for the course. The curriculum is approved by the state and adherence to it helps maintain the integrity of our writing sequence and composition program.

When we agree to teach WR 201, we agree to teach the curriculum as written at Irvine Valley College.

Here is the WR 201 curriculum:


COURSE CONTENT

(Lecture Topics Covered) 


  1. Critical Thinking/Reading
    1. Evaluation of Texts: Reading with a Critical Eye
      1. Determining the author's purpose, audience, and tone
      2. Recognizing the author's strategies for developing and supporting a claim
      3. Recognizing the author's deployment of organizational structures and matching of structures with rhetorical context
      4. Identifying and recognizing the characteristics/traits of a variety of texts
    2. The Making of Meaning: Juxtaposing the Reader's Context with the Text
      1. Relating the text to the personal experiences of students
      2. Relating the text to historical and/or current events
      3. Relating the text to other texts
      4. Relating the text to other courses
    3. Secondary Sources: Basic Library Skills
      1. Recognizing the availability and utility of library sources
      2. Employing basic library skills
      3. Considering the reliability of secondary sources
  2. Considerations for Analytical Writing
    1. Rhetorical Context: Recognizing the Elements and Understanding Their Significance
      1. Matching audience, purpose, and tone
      2. Selecting appropriate essay formats
    2. Text Generation: Conceptualizing and Creating a Text
      1. Recognizing and using a variety of strategies to generate ideas
      2. Recognizing and using a variety of strategies to develop and support a claim
      3. Recognizing and using a variety of organizational structures, matching structures with rhetorical contexts
      4. Recognizing and using strategies for revision in order to achieve unity and readability
    3. Text Generation: Using Sources
      1. Distinguishing among quotations, summary and paraphrase
      2. Using quotations, summary and paraphrase to support a claim
  3. Syntactical Considerations: Linking Audience Awareness with the Uses of Language and the Function of Correctness
    1. Revision strategies
      1. Reseeing concepts, rethinking ideas and reevaluating organization to achieve global revisions that create unity and coherence
      2. Reconsidering syntax, diction, grammar, mechanics, and reference to achieve local revisions that create clarity, coherence, and readability
  4. Manuscript Considerations: Matching Format with Rhetorical Context
    1. Adopting Standard Essay Format
      1. Distinguishing among various essay formats
      2. Considering the rhetorical context in order to match essay format to rhetorical purpose
    2. Observing the Conventions of Manuscript Preparation
      1. Recognizing the conventions of manuscript preparation
      2. Considering the rhetorical context and matching the conventions of manuscript preparation to rhetorical purpose
 COURSE CONTENT

(Learning Objectives) 


Upon completion of this course, the student will be able to:
  1. Explain and apply the role of audience, tone and purpose in writing, adapting the writing to match audience, purpose, and tone.
  2. Read critically to determine the writer's purpose, point of view, methods and manner of presentation.
  3. In response to a written text, propose and articulate a thesis, developing that thesis with effective and sufficient support, including support from primary and secondary sources.
  4. Identify, select and use various essay forms and assigned manuscript formats, matching organizational structures with rhetorical contexts.
  5. Revise for coherence, unity, content, and audience impact and edit to demonstrate competency in Standard Written English.
  6. Revise for conventions of manuscript preparation.




COURSE CONTENT 

(Methods of Evaluation) 

Evaluation of the student will be based upon the following items:

· In-class activities and formal essays that demonstrate student's ability to read critically a text to determine the writer's purpose, point of view, and methods and manner of presentations.

In-class and formal essays demonstrating the student's ability to adapt one's writing to match audience, purpose, and tone.

Prewriting activities such as journals, quotation charts, outlines, etc. that demonstrate student's ability to articulate and develop a thesis.

Peer-response and review activities, revision and metacogntion exercises that deomonstrate the student's ability to revise for coherence, unity, content, and audience impact and revise for conventions of manuscript preparation.


COURSE CONTENT
(Assignments) 
Reading:
Assigned texts, reflecting a broad spectrum of expression from the personal (memoir, personal experience) to the analytical and argumentative that support and enhance lecture topics.
Writing:
A minimum of four essays written in response to the critical reading of a text written by published author, a peer and/or self that require student to propose and articulate a thesis including support from primary and secondary sources. Exercises and scaffolded activities leading to the formulation and reconsideration of a completed essay in terms of coherence, unity, content, and audience impact.
Other:
Prewriting activities such as journals, quotation, charts, mini-essays, outlines, responses to questions, etc. Peer review. Research activities for primary and secondary sources.
Oral:
Presentations of an essay, group presentations, and/or debates/discussions.

*